Passion of the Roma:
A
George Raised by Four Georges and More
by Richard Oxman
George Weber, my
beloved mentor (of homosexual
persuasion), and author of the scholarly
Chinese Bronzes of the Late Chou
Period (1), once confided to me that
respecting sexual passion nothing
matched his lone experience with an
Andalusian flamenco dancer. A woman.
And on an intellectual plane, he
passionately defended the Roma's way of
life as equal to anything Chinese
civilization had to offer.
Their word for "to
know" (*chanelear*) included
the use of intuition, and that had won
him over in a deep way.
Weber's love for the
*gypsies* surged through his
pores. And stories poured out about how
this or that that he did provoked the
Roma to declare "ique gitano!" ("how
gypsy-like!")...over many meals, many
years. (2) He appreciated their
passionate contribution to the forces of
*anti-civilization*, and they,
in turn, showed their appreciation of
the academic *payo*. (3)
George Monbiot, in an
article which tries to reconcile
romanticizing the Roma and our envy of
them (4), shows quite clearly that
beneath the world's enduring hostility
to gypsies "lies an ancient envy of the
nomadic life." That the Latin root in *Civilization*
( "civis," a townsperson ) reveals how
"the culture of those whose homes do not
move" clashes with those who would not
be "sedentarised by decree." How and why
we "fear people whose mobility makes
them hard for our settled systems of
government to control."
Yet, not all gypsies
are nomadic. Most Spanish gypsies, for
example, are fairly well-integrated into
that country's society, retaining their
idiosyncratic culture without traveling
as per the common perception of Roma.
In fact, it is the gypsy passion for
something else that works up the common
*payo*.
To wit, the neurotic
way in which Westerners carefully plan
the whole of their lives is anathema to
the Roma, ( perceived as ) *anal
retentive* at best. Utterly
incomprehensible, really. According to
art historian/author Michael Jacobs, "In
their philosophy, to be practical is to
be boring and not to appreciate life to
the full." (5) He cites Irving Brown
(6), who points out: "Gypsies are not
content with spending their last cent:
in order to be happy they must defy all
sense of practicality."
This is a point of
view that is easily accessible in a film
such as Tony Gatliff's "The Crazy
Stranger" ( *Gadjo Dilo* ), but
not so in something like Guy Ritchie's
"Snatch." As much fun as the latter can
be, the work of Madonna's husband
portrays gypsies in a light that can be
easily misleading. Reassuringly so
to the run of the public. Gatliff's
work, on the other hand, is part of a
trilogy that's quite on target for the
most part. A welcome relief from the
ignorance compounded upon ignorance
concerning the Roma.
In literature, we
find a mixed-bag of responses to the
Roma, some misleading, some misinformed,
some well-meaning, some mean-spirited.
The great Cervantes had it all wrong
with his characterization of the gypsies
as thieving, "born into the world for
the sole purpose of being thieves, they
study in order to be thieves, and they
end up past masters in the art of
thieving." (7) Others, too, such as
Henry David Inglis, Theophile Gautier,
Alexandre Dumas *pere*, Baron
Charles Davillier, Thomas Roscoe
and Prosper Merimee (author of the
original Carmen, the inspiration
for Bizet's work) must all be approach
with various degrees of caution.
When one dips into
19th century Richard Ford and George
Borrow, however, one begins to enter
much healthier ground respecting the
passion of the Roma. And with Frederico
Garcia Lorca, a compassionate genius
(who my Uncle George knew quite well),
the air gets quite clear.
As the incomparable
Ian Gibson points out (in his definitive
biography of Lorca): "As a child the
poet had known various Romany families
in Fuente Vaqueros...and during his
adolescence frequently visited the caves
of the Sacromonte, where he made friends
with the dancers and singers. *Gypsy
Ballads* was to spring in part from
Lorca's contact with these exotic people
of Indian extraction...." (8)
Although it's true
that Lorca could never be relied upon to
tell the truth about himself, my Uncle
George assured me that the poet was
indeed feted by Gypsies as if he were
one of their own. If such is so, this
rarest of relationships should be
remembered by those seeking out
literature to enlighten...respecting the
passion of the Roma.
George Borrow,
eventual author of The Zincali: or an
Account of the Gypsies of Spain, had
his youthful interest in the Roma piqued
by privileged glimpses into gypsy
encampments in early
nineteenth-century Norfolk, England.
And that area, ironically, is not
so very far from a recent, impassioned
anti-gypsy demonstration which took
place in Firle, Sussex.
Of all the insights
offered by the Monbiot article mentioned
above, none is more devastating than the
official attitudes expressed regarding
injustice dealt to the Roma. Home
Secretary Jack Straw is quoted as
supporting notions which echo the
racist ignorance of Spain's
Isabella, King Philip IV, and many other
outdated prejudices. And Liberal
Democrat MP Norman Baker, normally
someone the Left can count on, provided
the most socially-unconscious lift to
skinheads imaginable.
In effect, the
Bonfire Society of Firle was encouraged
to burn in effigy a vehicle with
caricatures of gypsies festooned across
its windows.
Why? To answer that
we must return to my points about the
Passion of the Roma.
Their outlook on life
--which leads to great extremes of
pleasure and pain-- is not something
that today's dominant society can
condone. It's a very different
philosophy than that which is
exemplified by those, say, who partake
of extreme sports. Or disgusting
Reality TV. And only a very narrow
vision will pigeonhole them into the
same category.
For one, my subject
here is politically threatening,
the rest is not.
Excessive pleasure,
Uncle George once told me, is
the fulcrum which supports the
emotional, spiritual and physical life
of the Roma. And I've found that
confirmed by a number of sources. His
time with them in Santiago in Guadix and
la Chanca in Almeria -- and in other
European locales outside of Spain --
taught him that what the typical
Westerner recoiled from in horror (Deep
Passion over Death!) Gypsies embraced
wholeheartedly. They directed their
Sorrow, they didn't become its victim.
And coping with Sadness was much more
than getting by, *getting through*
an event.
The Politics of
Distress is much in evidence in our
civilized circles, the manicured way in
which we are subservient to Control.
The Gypsy doesn't
need to control his emotions. And
he/she certainly won't allow others to
do so...to him/her.
A gorgeous political
george, yes?
Richard Oxman, former
professor of Dramatic Art & Cinema
History at Rutgers University-Newark,
can be reached at
dueleft@yahoo.com. His recent
writing is available at
www.oxtogrind.org. Readers can make
legitimate (rare) contact with Roma
through his French Paintbox opeation (www.frenchpaintbox.com)
...sometimes.
Footnotes:
(1) A work which is
harder to penetrate than Joyce's
Ulysses, infinitely more
challenging. In my humbled opinion.
(2) Interesting how the
Roma invoke this laudatory phrase, given
their detestation -- throughout history
-- of the term gitano.
(3) "Payo" refers to
non-gypsy. It translates as *peasant*
or *serf*, but Weber -- a
highly distinguished Chairman of the Art
Department of Rutgers
University-Newark had no problem
whatsoever in being addressed so; to say
the least. Virtually no outsiders
are embraced by the Roma, and the simple
fact of being acknowledged at all was an
honor to George.
(4)
http://www.zmag.org/content/print_article.cfm?itemID=4445§ionID=30
The only objection I have to Monbiot's
piece is that the number of gypsies
condemned to death by Himmler in WWII
Europe is not to be *guesstimated*
at between 250,000 and 500,000, but
rather quite comfortably estimated as
400,000...*at a bare minimum*.
Victims of the civilized Germans,
numbers ignored quite commonly by those
civilized academics and others who
routinely run down the atrocities of
"The Holocaust" for us.
(5) Michael Jacobs, A
Guide to Andalusia (London: Viking,
1990), p. 133.
(6) Author of two
definitive works related to
this subject: Nights and Days on the
Gypsy Trail through Andalusia and on
other Mediterranean Shores and
Deep Song.
(7) Jacobs, op. cit.,
p. 125.
(8) Ian Gibson,
Frederico Garcia Lorca: A Life (New
York: Pantheon, 1989), p. 29.